Showing posts with label surly alex. Show all posts
Showing posts with label surly alex. Show all posts

Sunday, December 7, 2014

Blowing Off Some STEM

Am I the only one feeling a little tired of the obsessive focus on STEM (science, technology, engineering and math) not just in our educational circles, but in American culture overall?
I know these things go in cycles, but I feel like this trend has been dominating the discourse since the Cold War, with only occasional, brief time-outs to swing the other way (or, more often, to provide political cover that essentially changes nothing).  And now the movement has this shiny “STEM” branding that makes us think it’s an original development, when really it’s just the same old.
Yes, of course science and math and engineering and all that are important.  No one would suggest otherwise.  Kids need instruction in and exposure to all appropriate subject areas.
But no one ever suggests that every kid needs to come out of high school a poet.  Why does it feel that, on the contrary, we’re being told that every kid has to come out of high school an engineer?
Newsflash: some—lots of—kids’ brains don’t work well in the STEM area.  Just as we’ve always acknowledged that they don’t all work well in the lit-n-arts area.
You may say it’s not an issue—that I’m bemoaning a conflict without belligerents.
But when, exactly, in the past hundred years, have the STEM subjects  been at risk of disappearing in favor of literature, grammar, foreign languages, and the arts?
It is these latter subjects that are under constant threat of being cut, defunded, excised, and generally overwhelmed by the “hard stuff.”  Sounds like a conflict to me.

And while I appreciate the burgeoning “STEAM” variant that shoe-horns an “A” for “arts” in there, it doesn’t quite cut it for me.  For those who are sincerely trying to push this alternative, it seems like their efforts are still somewhat ghettoized, while when more “venerable” and entrenched education organizations adopt it, it feels like lip service.  It’s hard to take STEAM seriously as a force when STEM is still entrenched in the way the government discusses education and even immigration policy.
It’s explicitly science and technology, after all, that are enjoying a surge in high-visibility promotional campaigns.  I can’t turn on the TV without being reminded that “we’re not popular...but we know how computers work,” meaning that all those brainless bullies “will work for us someday.”  Revenge of the nerds via STEM!  How charming.

Then there are the big gas companies partnering with media conglomerates to turn sports into an opportunity for on-the-fly scientific analysis that would make NASA blush.  (Just once I’d like to see a commercial featuring a high school football player reflecting on the ways his chosen sport reveal the hidden nature of the human condition in the clash of antagonistic forces... )   I guess there’s always a chance that some of the kids Chevron is trying to inculcate here might end up pioneering ways to fight climate change, but that’s probably not high on any curricula they’re interested in designing.

The Connect-a-Million-Minds project is based entirely on this premise that sports and STEM go together.  Maybe I spoke too soon about  that nerd revenge.  Now I’m starting to feel like efforts are underway to cleanse all geeks from America’s shores--replace the STEMmy ones with jocks, reducing every engineering problem to “how to get the ball through the goal,”  and just ignore and defund the artsy ones out of existence.

And thus a great American dream for which the red-blooded nation has been striving since the 1950s will finally be accomplished.

I’m exaggerating, of course.  A little.  The point is, STEM is deeply entrenched in the planning process of American education policy, with curricula shaped to its needs, big-time corporate conglomerates for sponsors, and a propaganda arm as wide and bristly as Stalin’s accursed mustache.  STEM will be here to stay, while the vestigial appendage of the arts continues to wither, one French program and lit magazine and photography club at a time.

So, as in so much else, it should be the librarian’s task to pick up the slack.  Let us not give in to the drumbeat of all-consuming STEM.  Let’s fill our libraries with books, materials, and marketing for all things literary and artistic.  And not just for the kids—for the adults, too…you know, those larger, slightly lumbering things we insist we want to aid with “lifelong learning”?  For that matter, lifelong learning need not be limited to computer training.  That is, obviously, just as important for adults as for kids, if not more so.  But what about creative writing?  What about pottery?  What about poetry?  What about dance?
All kidding aside, the kids—and adults—whose brains work in the STEM mode will be very important to the future of our society.  They will be the computer engineers, the architects, the urban planners, the doctors, and the mathematicians and scientists charting unheard-of new discoveries.
But where will we be if we neglect the kids (and adults!) whose talents and temperaments lie in the arts?  These are the people who will be making the world a beautiful place.  They will be the people helping us laugh in troubled times.  They will be, like Dickens and Steinbeck and Morrison before them, the cartographers charting the moral landscape of our society.
It may be hard to pin a future value to that.  But look around the stacks of your library and tell me you can’t estimate the value they’ve had every day up to now.  Tell me you don’t think we should be fostering those skills and talents and temperaments just as ferociously as the STEMmy kids’.

Saturday, October 4, 2014

Viva Contrarianism?

I’m back after a long gap of preparing for, undergoing, and recovering from a pair of interviews--and I got the job!  I am now (or soon will be) an honest-to-goodness Adult Services Librarian.  Go me!

The main thing I regret is the timing--the fact that I missed out working on those Librarian High Holy Days, Banned Books Week.  I’d better have a great plan for next year.  But I also, fortunately,  missed out on another wave of anti-Banned Books Week sentiment, which seems to be ramping up in the librarian community as time goes on.  For some reason we librarians have to dig into “deep” questions about what it’s all *for*, what it *means*, is it *good* or *bad* and all that.

To me, it just reinforces my feeling that librarians are, culturally, a pack of self-defeating contrarians.

I think it has something to do with our desire to know that we are taken seriously academically and professionally.  There’s a tendency to be overly self-critical when faced with doubt from within or without.

We need to get over this lack of confidence in the way our field is perceived and our overweening fear of being misunderstood, or of not serving every angle of every point of view in everything we do.  We need to let go of this fear of not being “academic” or “rigorous” or “serious” enough.  Just keep being good at research--and writing papers on intersectionality in YA literature or whatever the flavor of the year may be--and we can be sure we’re ticking all the necessary boxes.

As for the problems with Banned Books Week specifically, it’s no great mystery how we should change our contrarian thinking.  No one with two brain cells (which, we have to admit, is the vast majority of people, despite cynical impressions to the contrary) will seriously think that we’re somehow in favor of banning books because of the name of a library event--so we need to scratch that overly cautious concern with “branding” and “messaging” right quick.  

Same thing with the semantic hand-wringing over the difference between “banned” and “challenged.”  One may be more accurate, but one is more visceral.  It’s not dishonest to go for the visceral reaction when we’re trying to grab attention.

And, perhaps most crucially, we can’t concern ourselves with every single nuance of the issue of intellectual freedom during the week in which the goal is, generally, just to raise awareness that such issues exist.  

The rest of the year is for working on your pet issues--and you should.  That one week in September might come off as sounding superficial in comparison to your deep insights into how, say, net neutrality affects some super-specific intersectional demographic.  But that’s the trouble with too much academic thinking in our field, or in any field, really--getting so specific and technical that we ignore the kinds of language and efforts that can actually educate the general public in a meaningful way.

If we can accept the celebration’s role as such, I’ll be a lot happier next year when I take part in my first professional observance of Banned Books Week.  

Meanwhile, November 15 is International Games Day, so I’d better get to work thinking about what my new library will be doing to celebrate!

Sunday, June 29, 2014

ALA, Sustain Thyself

I’m putting my scold hat back on because I look so good in it.  But I’ll try to keep it brief.

Look: Las Vegas is an unsustainable city.  So why is the American Library Association hosting its annual conference there as we speak?

http://bit.ly/1yZY38i

ALA supports environmental sustainability, as evidenced by the recent establishment of Sustainability Round Table.  Its charge is to move the profession forward “toward a more equitable, healthy and economically viable society;” its mission is “is to provide resources for the library community to support sustainability through curriculum development; collections; exhibits; events; advocacy, communication, library buildings and space design..”

I can’t think of a bigger library “event” than the ALA annual conference, and yet I can’t imagine a worse venue for it, from a sustainability perspective, than Las Vegas.  Water scarcity, air quality, urban sprawl and energy use are all major issues in Las Vegas--issues that are fed by tourist interest, and exacerbated by desires for quick fixes for human comfort, rather than systemic improvements.  (Don’t take my word for it--here’s a presentation given by a British schoolteacher.  You can trust anything delivered in a British accent, even when it’s only in writing.)

To be fair, the city is trying.  This article highlights the environmental problems facing Vegas as well as the efforts that the mega-business owners of the Strip are making to ameliorate matters.  Such efforts are admirable, but nothing will change the fact that living in and visiting places like Las Vegas and Phoenix just perpetuates the problems that such initiatives are scrambling to fix.  And no subterranean stream is going to help the mess that is the Colorado River, whose decline is helped along by Sin City’s demands for water.  The fact is that humans weren’t meant to live in deserts, much less vacation there in luxury.

http://bit.ly/1m0mCfo

And yet ALA chose to bring its conference, and the dollars of thousands of librarians, to this energy-sucking, man-made desert oasis whose bright lights can be seen from space.

With a world full of options, why do we choose to support one that is so in conflict with an important contemporary value?  

And much of what I’ve seen on social media from my colleagues is excitement.  I’ll admit it, when I first heard ALA ‘14 would be held in Vegas, I was excited too.  That was before it sunk in what it meant.  Let’s get serious: this is a city composed of knock-offs, built as a shrine to the act of gambling.  It’s a playground.  Any true beauty and culture developed as an afterthought.  When I considered what it costs to power, cool, transport, and light the place--and I’m not just talking dollars--I decided that there was nothing to get excited about.

All for the sake of a playground.

I’d like to be able to say that I’m sitting on my couch at home in Western New York right now because I decided to be principled and boycott ALA.  Alas, I didn’t have the money to go anyway, rendering any such intent to boycott meaningless.  Nor did I get my thoughts together in time to make a plea for other librarians to consider foregoing this year’s conference.  I’m not being a very effective activist right now, am I?  But that doesn’t detract from the importance of stating my view, and hoping that there are others out there who agree with me.  Maybe we can mobilize to make our feelings known, and prevent ALA from making a return to the heart of unsustainability.

What’s the endgame, if I get my way?  Well, if ALA made it a part of their platform not to patronize such cities, maybe the organizations that look to us and respect our values will make similar moves.  That could end up rippling out, as libraries effect publishers, who effect distributors, who effect and effect and effect...

Which leaves the question of how to get ALA to listen.  Boycotting is one way, and the great thing is that we can still get the benefit of programs and sessions without being there in person.  Lots of them are accessible asynchronously, and their materials are available for the asking.  Maybe not every little thing can be found without paying for some kind of attendance, but librarians aren’t really known for limiting access (especially when they’re presenters excited about their topic of interest).

A formal petition to ALA could also have an effect.  I’m going to look into starting one through one of the grassroots activism groups out there.  If you agree with parts of what I’m saying, watch out for that; I’d appreciate your support.

Finally, all those of us who care about the environment, and want to bring librarianship to a leading role in its defense, should join the Sustainability Round Table.  It’s ten bucks to join, which I don’t mind paying at all.  The point of this isn’t to punish ALA, after all, but to get its attention.  What better way than to see a flow of money going into the round table, rather than toward registration for the next unsustainable conference?

In the parlance of Sin City, I’m putting my money on green.

http://bit.ly/1x0Y2in

Tuesday, December 10, 2013

Guns in Libraries: In which Alex courts controversy

A decision by the Michigan state Supreme Court ruled on November 21 that the state’s gun laws prohibit libraries from banning firearms from their premises.  Excuse me a moment while I gag.


…


Sorry, thought that would make me feel better, but it didn’t.  Oh well.  


My feelings on gun ownership in general should be obvious, and this ruling now forces me to confront the possibility that my chosen place of work will be less of a safe haven than I would have liked.  More important, the library as an institution will seem like less of a safe haven to patrons around the country that we are trying to woo through our doors, not drive away from them.


Because, unfortunately, the Michigan situation is not an isolated one.  Seattle library patrons are now free to carry through the stacks as well, while Minnesota library visitors have been able to pack heat right along, though residents recently learned that the law is even looser than they thought.  And in Richmond, protesters have staged a demonstration to convince library officials to abandon a policy that they claimed did not clearly-enough enshrine their right to carry a concealed deadly weapon in the library building.


They did so while flaunting the heat they were packing.


The Michigan case was actually sparked by a protest in which gun advocates marched through the Lansing library with weapons bared.  They responded to a policy designed to avoid panic by engaging in the panic-inducing behavior itself.  


Are these folks right to demand that libraries acquiesce to their version of Constitutional rights?  Does the nature of libraries require us to craft our policies in such a way that the right to concealed weapons is protected in our buildings?


The Grey Area


Libraries exist in a bit of a grey area between public and private space.  Are they a public institution?  They take our tax money, they’re open to all, they claim to be there to serve our needs, and librarians often describe themselves as public servants.  The word ‘public’ is right there in the name some of these organizations use!  Thus, one could argue, libraries have no call to limit the rights ensured by our most sacred legal documents, any more than the government does.


Yet at the same time, libraries are webbed with a complicated network of self-determined regulations.  They are not a monolithic institution administered by the federal government, but a patchwork of many administrative practices and organizational origins, from the hands-on of local government to the near-autonomy of pseudo-corporations.  No one criticizes their prerogative to deny service based on any number of common-sense considerations.  Libraries routinely decide whom they serve and do not serve--the most prominent variable, for better or worse, based on perceived indigence.  People get banned from libraries every day for a great variety of infractions determined in-house.  


And everyone knows that the word ‘public’ in ‘public libraries’ really just describes, broadly, its target user base, right?--so as to set them apart from the more sharply-defined school, academic and special libraries, demonstrating that each of these is clearly cloistered to one extent or another.


In short, ‘public library’ does not mean ‘federal agency library,’ and is thus not one of the institutions that the Bill of Rights is meant to protect us against.


The physical access prerogative


The fact is that you’d probably have to look at each public library in turn to determine its level of autonomy, but most of them exist within systems where they are granted significant leeway to determine their service parameters themselves.  So the hand-wringing over the rights of gun owners to carry in a library is a bit of a canard--library administrators have as much authority to determine who is allowed within their walls, and why, as any grocery store or coffee shop manager.


I find it amusing that second amendment fetishists are often among the same people who believe ("in theory," to be sure) that business owners should be able to limit who patronizes their enterprises based on race or sexual orientation, yet they bristle violently at the idea of an institution that limits its patronage based on whether or not they put their gun away before coming over.  It’s a funny twist.


If I knew a man was carrying a knife in his pocket at my library, I’d ask him to leave and come back without it, and there are no laws against that--and it would be completely controversy-free if it accorded with my library’s policies.  But swap a knife for a gun and those policies become suspect.


But is it possible to consider that my position--that gun owners should be asked not to carry weapons into my library--is as unethical as I believe limitations based on race or sex or orientation to be?  


I would say no.  This is a public safety issue, not one of discrimination based on an immutable or quintessential personal characteristic.  It’s not an integral hardship to leave your gun behind when you venture into various public and private spheres--you take it home, you come back-- whereas a person can’t stop being black or gay to gain such access. Being barred on the basis of those immutable qualities  can cause a great deal of emotional distress.


Gun owners might claim emotional distress at being barred entry with their guns, but to me that means they are either emotionally unstable, lying to accentuate their case, or both.


A gun is an object, nothing more.  Put another way, I really like my Game of Thrones memorabilia, but if, upon entering a library, I learned that it constituted a potential disruption to other patrons’ use of the space, I’d depart and leave it home next time.  


And if you are too afraid to face the world without your deadly security blanket, I’m not sure what to say to you.


Why I feel like guns suck in general


Let’s talk about that, then--the why of carrying guns about to begin with, not just in libraries, but anywhere.  


Gun owners like to say that their armed presence can prevent or reduce the severity of violent tragedies.  They also like to tout themselves as more responsible and ‘more law-abiding’ than other law-abiding citizens, whatever that means.  But I don’t think we can take that claim seriously as long as this keeps happening.


And it happens a lot.  Guns left for kids to kill themselves, guns left in public restrooms, guns accidentally discharging at gun safety courses, well-trained public safety officials making blunders with their guns--this stuff happens with alarming regularity.  


But we should permit such accidents to continue based on the slim hope that a gun-wielding good guy will successfully land a killshot on a shooter in a highly stressful, less-than-ideal firing situation?  Sorry, my library should not become a war zone in response to the actions of a single disturbed individual.


The last word you need to hear on the subject should be this: “Children between the ages of 5 and 14 are eleven times more likely to die from an accidental gunshot [in the United States] than in other developed nations.” Clearly more guns are not the answer.


The library is supposed to make everyone feel welcome, but welcoming gun owners with their weapons would make a lot of people uncomfortable.  I’m one of them.  People don’t want weapons in the place where they learn, browse, take their kids.  By their nature, they are deadly objects, all too prone to accident.  That’s why many libraries have policies against such things, and why I am aghast at the trend epitomized by the  Michigan ruling.


I welcome all people to the library, gun owners included.  They should be comfortable in any public library in the nation.  But not with their weapons.  I do not welcome them.


Final Words


My personal preference is obviously for the barring of firearms of all kinds from libraries, and I think we have a legitimate case for saying that it’s legal and precedented to impose such a ban.  Writing implements, recording equipment, communication devices, and so on are already banned in many libraries and no one screams ‘infringement of first amendment rights.’  


Furthermore, all kinds of activities that are constitutionally protected are, nonetheless, abridged for appropriate reasons in certain contexts.  Public safety and security is one of those reasons.  And again, the Bill of Rights delineates protections you have against your government, not other individuals or entities.  (That’s why Sarah Palin is wrong every time she screeches about infringement of her First Amendment rights when journalists speak against various crackpot policies she espouses.)


But I get that there are laws and a Constitution that says you can have guns  and places in the country where it might actually be the will of the majority of people to carry them in public places.


Fine.  I’ll avoid those parts of the country.  


The big problem I have is when pro-gun advocates turn libraries into weapon-strewn circuses to make a political point, potentially dismaying patrons in the process.  Flaunting your firearms, knowing full well that in any public context, there will be people who are uncomfortable with being in the presence of such items--and with good reason--is not responsible activism for your cause.


(For what it’s worth, I believe that in-your-face activism is appropriate when it comes to causes that aren’t related to advocacy for items or activities representing a threat to bodily function.  Gay kiss-ins, a-okay; gun-waving rallies, not so much.  A gay kiss won’t kill you, but one overly-caffeinated gun-nut in a crowd of otherwise responsible protesters might.)


Advocate for your position.  Sign petitions.  Hold signs outside the building and march around a bit.  Call your congressman and your library board members.  These are all examples of responsible political action.


Gun-waving in protest of a ban, when the point of that ban is to spare people the anxiety  that guns induce, and the actual danger that they represent--whether they are concealed or otherwise--is inflammatory, designed to stoke fear and to silence opponents.  It’s intimidation.

There’s a word for getting your way through fear and intimidation: terrorism.

Wednesday, August 28, 2013

Get Over Yourself, You Overgrown Damaged Adolescent: A Non-Spoiler Review of Patrick Rothfuss' The Name of the Wind

Bonus post!  I just wrote this over at Goodreads and thought I'd share my salty mood with you all today.  And okay, sure, there is maybe one very mild spoiler, but it doesn't really reveal anything.  Read on!

There's nothing worse than a good story poorly told, unless it's a mostly good story mostly poorly told.  I'm not sure which this book is, but either way it's bad news.

186074
Image taken from www.goodreads.com

I've seen Rothfuss and his work ballyhooed for some years now and was really looking forward to the chance to get into the first book of "The Kingkiller Chronicles."  By all accounts, it seemed to be a genre-mover, an epochal work that moves the boundaries of fantasy forward while paying homage to the best of what came before.  I was intrigued by the promise of a frame narrative, of a famous man mysteriously brought low, and of a creeping, misunderstood, demonic threat.  There seemed to be echoes of my loves, "The Wheel of Time" and "A Song of Ice and Fire" in the promised themes of real-world events turning to legend and myth before our eyes and of the meaning made by stories determined by the skewed perspectives of the individuals through whose eyes the stories are experienced.  It all sounds so good!

Sadly the book does not deliver.  Or it only delivers up to a point, which makes it supremely frustrating rather than just bad.

First of all, Rothfuss' work needs to come with a trigger warning for grammar-lovers.  Seriously, how did this book get past first draft like this?  Who is this guy's editor?  He or she should be canned immediately.  Small but noticeable problems abound, the most frequent being an inconsistent and maddening lack of facility with the conventions of dialogue and tags.  "'I think,' he said. 'That you are pretty.'"--that is NEVER RIGHT.  (Okay, it's right if your character hesitates and makes the statement into two sentences.  But if that's the case you should let us know that that is happening.  And I know, Patrick Rothfuss, that you were just doing it wrong, because you did it 50-75% of the time.)

Sorry.  I feel strongly that writers should know how to write.

The next big problem: the main character, Kvothe, is a baaaad example of whatever the male equivalent of a Mary Sue would be called.  Let's say a Marvin Sue.  (Oh, I guess some people say 'Gary Stu.'  I like mine better.)  The point is.  Kvothe is perfect perfect perfect, he was better at everything as an 8 year old than you will ever be at your one passion in life at age 30, he runs rings around the authorities, and everything bad in his life is inflicted upon him by his enemies and/or his cruel destiny, boo-hoo for Kvothe, but wait, thanks to his daring and cunning, he always gets his way in the end!  This human being is SO. DAMN.  FRUSTRATING.  And yes, he's charming, and occasionally shows some sensitivity, just enough to get you to want to follow his story and feel bad for him.  But his entire personality is so much revenge porn for the downtrodden nerdlings of the real world, and, speaking as one of them, I feel like we deserve better than that kind of pandering in our fiction.

(To say nothing of Kvothe's supposedly rapier-sharp wit.  Seriously, he talks like the picked-on kid in the schoolyard who hasn't yet come up with any better coping mechanisms.  But Kvothe is rewarded with gales of laughter at every turn.  Sigh.)

Then there's this authorial tendency throughout the text to seem tragically holier-than-thou compared to all that *snooty voice* run of the mill fantasy.  We're constantly reminded how real life isn't like the stories and Kvothe has to work so much harder than the heroes of his world's folklore and mythology because god damn it there is no God or Narrator who's just going to hand us a win.  Rothfuss makes such a point of it that it's obvious we're supposed to perceive Kvothe's story as this somehow rarefied, uber-realistic version of fantasy that, aside from magical metaphysics, abides by real-world laws of cause & effect and rationality and whatnot.  At one point, he says something very much like, "I wasn't going to find their plans written out on an accidentally-discarded piece of paper!"

A few pages later, enter the convenient plot swineherd.  He only travels this remote area once in a while, but he happens to be here at the same time as Our Hero, with not only the info Kvothe's looking for but also additional intelligence to propel the plot forward.

Look, I'm all for dissecting fantasy tropes and realism now and then.  But don't preach about it and then substitute the deus ex machina you just had your character basically decry as lazy writing with another one that you hope your audience won't notice (or perhaps that you, yourself, did not notice).

The sanctimonious attitude gets old, and it extends to Kvothe's rhapsodizing about music, about how non-musicians just can't understand beauty and love and perfection.  Oh, God's body, get over yourself, Patrick Rothfuss, you overgrown damaged adolescent.

And yeah, now I'm reading book 2.  That's the most frustrating part.  I almost feel as though Rothfuss structured his story as cynically as possible, knowing that no matter how disagreeable readers find the first volume, they will want the full story on all the hints and clues and intriguing bits seeded throughout.  I feel manipulated, and I'm 7% in and grinding my teeth at the same old usage errors, but I'm not stopping.

And yet this book is as highly-rated as I've seen anywhere.  I don't get it.  I honestly don't.  I'm usually fine letting people have their taste and enjoy their enjoyment ("I don't want to yuck your yum"), but this book violates the various laws and maxims and pet peeves that I've seen cited by numerous readers complain about OTHER books.  (Poorly written--check.  Mary Sue--check.  Sanctimonious underpinnings--check.  Manipulative--check.)  And everyone is eating it up.  I am saddened.

Maybe this will convince you to trash this book: Rothfuss writes "make do" as "make due."  Twice.

*cheery smile*  I hate what you've done to us, Patrick Rothfuss.