This is a pretty direct transposition of an exchange I had on Facebook with a friend in response to this Humans of New York post. I decided to present my mostly off-the-cuff response here, unedited and unalloyed, because I've seen a petition going around combating the contentious situation described by the Human of New York in question.
You're entitled to your opinion on the matter; this is mine.
[Context: my friend posted the entry to my Wall with the comment "DO NOT LIKE." To which I go...]
I'm of two minds about this. The gut reaction is, of course, that this must be a bad thing (and I'm willing to give more credence to it as bad due to my own experience and the fact that this is a sentiment held by at least one employee of the institution). There's history here, and more importantly, there's access. We don't want to lose those.
However.
In today's day and age, there's really no reason we need to take up space on-site with research material in many locations--especially not in midtown Manhattan, where space is at such a premium, and where that space might be better spent fostering creativity and community in an all-too-often cloistered culture.
What about all that lovely research material, you say? Well, depending on the system NYPL is able to put in place, there's no reason why it shouldn't remain just as accessible to the conscientious researcher as it is now. People don't realize all the time that the main library there is a closed stacks environment anyway--you can't just walk around browsing and take what you want. With the collection removed, if you're going to spend a few hours researching, you can submit requests and probably have what you need in your hands within the hour. The canny researcher may well submit such requests ahead of time and have it all waiting for him upon arrival. (Now, whether that works out in real life will probably be a process of working out kinks and dealing with the reality of the Lincoln and Holland Tunnels. Not ideal, but for the trade-off...)
And on top of that, most of the research people are going to do these days probably won't involve dusty tomes from 1850. Maybe some, but even a lot of that is being digitized. So that being the case, why should we take up seven stories of the most premium real estate in the world with books that people might want to use out of nostalgia, but don't actually *need* to use?
I'm a proponent of what detractors sneeringly refer to "library-as-internet-cafe." Because that isn't what it's about--we're not trying to be Barnes and Noble. But we do have to compete with Barnes and Noble (and, increasingly, Amazon). So we might offer some superficial perks here and there to get bodies in the building. What's awesome is the stuff we do with the bodies once we have them.
Wait, that came out wrong.
(Disclaimer: Though I have been somewhat following this story, I don't know all of what NYPL plans to do with the research collection and how it plans to provide access to it. My comments are based primarily on the models offered by certain other institutions but which, if NYPL is smart--and it is run by some very smart people who write job descriptions I will never qualify for--they will emulate. And no, this doesn't answer the shameful reduction in the business etc. materials, which I hope they are making sensible provisions for as well.)
...
(PS This article confirms many of my dim recollections and assumptions, and adds a few more details and heartily-worded statements of support for the new model: http://acrlog.org/2012/05/07/the-new-york-public-library-central-library-plan-and-its-critics/
I do hope that what NYPL is trying to do, in its considered and professionally vetted way, won't be subverted by the kneejerk reactions of people wedded to the past and with no knowledge of oncoming trends.)
And the more I think about it, the less leeway I'm willing to give Chicken Guy, because he seems the most overly-nostalgic and kneejerk of them all.
-----
Now, my fellow librarians--where do you stand on this issue? And anyone else, feel free to chime in.
Showing posts with label library closings. Show all posts
Showing posts with label library closings. Show all posts
Sunday, April 13, 2014
Sunday, May 19, 2013
Cutbacks on prime temporal real estate
I've been living it up in Miami and Miami Beach the past little whiles, having journeyed down here to visit my lovely and ever-patient boyfriend via Amtrak, stopping in NYC and DC along the way to see friends. (10-ish days in south Florida adds up to a large chunk of the month with long train rides at either end.) So, while there have been no posts here for a while, I wanted to send out a brief one lest my millions of loyal fans think this blog has gone the way of every other public writing outlet I have tried to establish over the years.
So, what I had initially wanted to write about was something positive--the first of my library critique photo essays, for which I have been gathering copious material over the past few months. My aim is to demonstrate that every library, no matter how tiny or how specialized, has amazing things to offer the public. Sadly, I'm going to have to proactively harsh that mellow with this post, as I came upon a library situation the other day that rather frustrated me.
The public library branch in Coconut Grove--an affluent, tourist-drenched suburb of Miami along opulent coastline--was closed on Friday afternoon. And the sign said it would be closed Sunday as well.
It upsets me that libraries find themselves having to close twice a week due to economic conditions. I can understand one day a week, but two is an awful lot and I hope it's only because of the economy that this, and other libraries in other communities, are closed that often. (Given my druthers, funding and staffing would be at adequate levels to open every library seven days a week without overworking anybody, but that's just me.)
What really bothers me, though, is the choice this library has made, or has had thrust upon it, of which days to be closed. The weekend is prime time for library visits, circulation, and programming, yet here two thirds of the weekend are out of commission. I can't help thinking that this isn't too much of a bother for the wealthy Floridians spending the summer in nearby gated communities such as the Cloisters (and how many of them do you think even use the library except for occasional ivory tower descents to check out genealogical info or have their new tablets explained to them?). However, not much farther up the road is a much more economically distressed part of the area that would probably benefit from having a library open when they're not at work and when their kids are not in school--and Saturday alone just doesn't cut it for me.
So, failburgers all around, I say. Not to pass too harsh judgment on this branch and its system, since I don't know what led to their decision to close those days--maybe they even determined that those days work for some reason--but it brings to mind the many hundreds of libraries making tough cutbacks in hours.
I'm curious--if your library (either where you work or where you visit) had to be closed two days a week, which do you feel would be optimum to avoid impacting access as much as possible? Or would you get creative? Me, I'd opt to close down altogether on Wednesdays, then shave hours from the early mornings and/or late evenings to make up the second day, which is what I think the library I volunteer at did. (The hour-shaving, not the Wednesday closing.)
However you shave it, losing out on prime temporal real estate does not seem like the best answer.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)