Showing posts with label role of LIS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label role of LIS. Show all posts

Sunday, April 13, 2014

The Fate of 42nd

This is a pretty direct transposition of an exchange I had on Facebook with a friend in response to this Humans of New York post.  I decided to present my mostly off-the-cuff response here, unedited and unalloyed, because I've seen a petition going around combating the contentious situation described by the Human of New York in question.

You're entitled to your opinion on the matter; this is mine.

[Context: my friend posted the entry to my Wall with the comment "DO NOT LIKE."  To which I go...]

I'm of two minds about this.  The gut reaction is, of course, that this must be a bad thing (and I'm willing to give more credence to it as bad due to my own experience and the fact that this is a sentiment held by at least one employee of the institution).  There's history here, and more importantly, there's access.  We don't want to lose those.

However.

In today's day and age, there's really no reason we need to take up space on-site with research material in many locations--especially not in midtown Manhattan, where space is at such a premium, and where that space might be better spent fostering creativity and community in an all-too-often cloistered culture.

What about all that lovely research material, you say?  Well, depending on the system NYPL is able to put in place, there's no reason why it shouldn't remain just as accessible to the conscientious researcher as it is now.  People don't realize all the time that the main library there is a closed stacks environment anyway--you can't just walk around browsing and take what you want.  With the collection removed, if you're going to spend a few hours researching, you can submit requests and probably have what you need in your hands within the hour.  The canny researcher may well submit such requests ahead of time and have it all waiting for him upon arrival.  (Now, whether that works out in real life will probably be a process of working out kinks and dealing with the reality of the Lincoln and Holland Tunnels.  Not ideal, but for the trade-off...)

And on top of that, most of the research people are going to do these days probably won't involve dusty tomes from 1850.  Maybe some, but even a lot of that is being digitized.  So that being the case, why should we take up seven stories of the most premium real estate in the world with books that people might want to use out of nostalgia, but don't actually *need* to use?

I'm a proponent of what detractors sneeringly refer to "library-as-internet-cafe."  Because that isn't what it's about--we're not trying to be Barnes and Noble.  But we do have to compete with Barnes and Noble (and, increasingly, Amazon).  So we might offer some superficial perks here and there to get bodies in the building.  What's awesome is the stuff we do with the bodies once we have them.

Wait, that came out wrong.

(Disclaimer: Though I have been somewhat following this story, I don't know all of what NYPL plans to do with the research collection and how it plans to provide access to it.  My comments are based primarily on the models offered by certain other institutions but which, if NYPL is smart--and it is run by some very smart people who write job descriptions I will never qualify for--they will emulate.  And no, this doesn't answer the shameful reduction in the business etc. materials, which I hope they are making sensible provisions for as well.)

...

(PS This article confirms many of my dim recollections and assumptions, and adds a few more details and heartily-worded statements of support for the new model: http://acrlog.org/2012/05/07/the-new-york-public-library-central-library-plan-and-its-critics/
I do hope that what NYPL is trying to do, in its considered and professionally vetted way, won't be subverted by the kneejerk reactions of people wedded to the past and with no knowledge of oncoming trends.)

And the more I think about it, the less leeway I'm willing to give Chicken Guy, because he seems the most overly-nostalgic and kneejerk of them all.

-----

Now, my fellow librarians--where do you stand on this issue?  And anyone else, feel free to chime in.

Monday, July 22, 2013

Foster the Best Impulses

I visited friends over the weekend in Ithaca; one of them is staying there to work for the summer, and it was the first geographic opportunity for four of us, friends since high school, to all get together in the same place at the same time in many years.  It was a wonderful reunion, but I won’t get into all the boy-watching debauchery here.

The three of us who were left on Saturday found ourselves armed with a set of ridiculous photo-booth pictures and decided we had to arts-and-crafts them into commemorative picture frames.  Cue the trip to the pharmacy to make copies and to Bed, Bath & Beyond to tiredly heckle a sweet assistant manager named Isaac (we love you, Isaac) and buy matching frames, followed by a frantic slice and dice until we had three charming keepsakes for our walls.

One of my friends mentioned that if we hadn’t all been together to put this together, it would likely have stayed on her to-do pile for months, if not forever.  The rest of us agreed.  It didn’t matter whether we had all the supplies and the best will in the world; it would get pushed off, superseded, a folder in the good intentions file.

But together, we had the positive pressure of community, the immediacy provided by shared experience, to spur us to complete our task.  I use the word ‘task,’ but it’s a pleasure--the first thing many of us decide is not important enough to take up space in our busy lives--and a pleasure heightened by working on it together.

Libraries can provide that community and that immediacy, spurring patrons to get down to brass tacks on those feel-good projects right away.  Whether the library budget can sustain the collection of art supplies or participants have to bring their own, there is no price for those primary, invaluable  commodities.  

Market your library as the place for get-togethers of all types to end up.  It could be a small reunion like the one I had this weekend, or it could be the bachelorette party, the retirement gala, the high school reunion.  Instead of leaving the commemoration or memorializing to one person or a committee, let it be the capstone of the group fun.  Leverage the sense of community and immediacy into a way to keep your community’s to do lists uncluttered and happy!

And provide that feeling for those who aren’t part of some big group or formal event.  Set a table aside for patrons to gather and foster a feeling of community even among strangers.  These resources, these ineffable feelings that occasionally drive us, need not be rigidly situational.  Libraries are the perfect place to set up the conditions for the community to thrive creatively, so foster those impulses while they’re hot and stoke them when they’re cool!

Thursday, June 20, 2013

Over-involved

It's just about a week until that holiest of weekends, the American Library Association Annual Conference.  This year it will be held in Chicago, Illinois (for fun and profit) and, as I believe I mentioned in my inaugural post, I'll be attending with three other freshly-hatched librarians from the UB LIS program!  We're all very excited, especially as this year's theme is Science-Fiction and Fantasy: The Factual and the Counterfactual.  Oh no, wait, it's Experimentation and Innovation in Libraries: What We Can Learn from Startups. No, that's not it! My mistake.  It's Introduction to RDA and Ontologies for the Semantic Web.

Not really.  In fact, the conference doesn't actually have a theme; the three that I listed above are merely the names of three of the many programs happening across the four days librarians take over the Windy City.  The many, many programs.  I mean, unless the tagline on the ALA Annual website--"Transforming our libraries, ourselves"--is meant to be a theme, in which case it's so general as to be not really very useful, and, based on my very thorough survey of all those programs, not particularly binding of presenters' focus--which, we can all agree, rather defeats the purpose of having a theme at all.

Now, I don't really mind this, myself.  We have a varied field and we all approach our corners of it in our own way.  I would rather give all my librarian buddies full range in which to develop presentations and poster sessions and so forth than force them all into any particular thematic cubbyhole for the year, however expansive a cubbyhole it may be. (And, again, expansiveness of theme has a certain limit beyond which it starts to get self-defeating.)

But I did run across a peer voicing concern with this tendency toward sprawl on a social network group the other day.  He worries that the breadth of offerings at ALA Annual bespeak a certain lack of coherence and discipline on the part of our profession.  And despite my above approbation, I think he has a point.

You can't take my approval of sprawl as evidence that everything is dandy--I am, after all, lacking in coherence and discipline myself.  My ALA schedule runs the gamut from graphic novels to Deaf culture to LGBTQ support to late-night programming and LITERALLY EVERYTHING in between.  If I could tame my own incoherence I might be happier, but I would almost certainly have less fun.

So is that it--is our profession undisciplined?  Are we less of a single body than, say, dentists?  (A dangerous force, dentists.)  Are we the professional equivalent of the over-involved college student, desperate for a snatch of everything campus life has to offer--drama club, newspaper, debate team, track and field--taking part in a little bit of everything but excelling at nothing? When the Meta-Librarian gets together with the Ur-Dentist and the Quintessential CPA and all the other Professionals Up In The Sky, are we the guy whose face everybody knows but whose name they can't place?  Is that the source of our under-appreciation and our embattlement in society at large?

We are very good at some specialized things, and I would never give up our engagement in the cultural, intellectual, and academic lives of our patrons.  And I still believe that's a good thing.  But is it possible there is a better thing? A leaner, meaner librarian? Slam, bam, reference interview, thank you, ma'am?

I think it bears some questioning.  As long as we keep all the extra-curriculars I'm interested in; I'll work on my self-discipline later.  Meanwhile, I think my dentist would REALLY like to hear about my Deaf LGBTQ overnight treasure hunt program idea.

UPDATE: "Transforming our libraries, ourselves" is, in fact, the conference theme.  I guess that's cool!

Wednesday, May 1, 2013

Why 'Librarianism'?


Well, you all made it through my first couple of blog posts, so your reward is a much shorter one!  I’d like to cover something that should have been the subject of my first post, but it kind of took second place to addressing the situation in Boston that week.  Nevertheless, I will tackle it now--why did I name my blog ‘Librarianism’?

There are a couple other blogs with the name out there, thus my inclusion of the word ‘viva’ in the url.  My apologies to those who have gone before, but I figured my way was clear, as those blogs seemed inactive, and their use of the word ‘librarianism’ didn’t seem to have any especial political bearing on their content in the way it does on mine.

I have an idealistic notion of the place of ‘-ism’ in our world.  It gets a lot of guff, mainly from its association with a certain Red Menace of yesteryear, whose influence I theorize has colored certain folks’ perception of anything ending in those three letters ever since, no matter how benign.  Or, if not exactly benign, then no matter how positively if uncomfortably transformative.

To me, the main purpose of the ‘-ism’ appendage is to transform an identity into a movement.  The ‘-ism’ makes a statement that there is a body of goals and characteristics--not necessarily shared by every member of the group, but which every member can point to and agree makes up the tapestry of a collective identity they all share, an identity that is bigger than stereotype and misconception, an identity that is worth making known.

And so it is with librarians.  We are legion, and we are varied, but we almost invariably share certain common goals and values.  Those are well known to most of my audience, and for others, I’ll be getting into some of them in the future.  For now, suffice it to say that to turn ‘librarian’ into ‘librarianism’ is to turn those values, all too often idle in the midst of day-to-day library management and customer service, into action.

(I should mention that I don’t presume to be one of a few librarians leading active, value-driven careers.  There are many who live according to their versions of my idealized actionable librarian values, and have done so since long before I was born.  My only presumption is to throw my hat in the ring with them, and offer my particular views on the action in that ring.)

I would consider myself on the radical edge of the librarianist tapestry.  I’m still figuring out what that means.  There’s the intellectual freedom angle, there’s the LGBTQ service and access angle, there’s the inclusion of non-traditional materials angle, and so on--but those are hardly unique to me, or even at all remarkable among librarians.  Even my desire to confront the conventional wisdom of the profession, to shake up the foundations of our training--these are not really radical among my peers, in that they seem to be widely accepted concerns in the community, if to different degrees from librarian to librarian.

I can sum up my radicalism, I think--such as it is--in my assertion of what ‘service’ really means.  Service to our patrons and our communities, I believe, entails more than simply serving what they like and what they ‘need’ in a sort of subsistence fashion, but to look deeper, to push their boundaries, to see what is coming next; and then presenting it, advocating for it, and making our communities uncomfortable until they adapt.  I think you can see the trouble with that philosophy, compared to the library’s ‘traditional role,’ dictated as it is in part by the community’s approbation (and funding).  I stand by it, though.  We’ll talk.

But that is something I intend to get into in much greater depth down the line.  Sooner, I will treat you all to the instance of librarian-on-librarian intellectual aggression that actually compelled me to start this blog.  And after that, we can get into that time (yesterday) when I got into a fight with a more senior librarian about her deceased cat.  Not really.  But kind of.  And there’s a lesson in every tale!

But first, a library photo essay.  Look for that next week, if I find time during my trip to Miami Beach.  Have a good time in the meanwhile!  Mix it up and make it squirrely!

(Feel free to help me out with my sign-off.)

Saturday, April 20, 2013

Something to think about


I hope everyone had a very good National Library Week.

I get that it was probably difficult to focus on libraries in this time of crisis.  Though the events surrounding the Boston Marathon bombing were essentially local, the ongoing ubiquity of social media made it a part of our lives like no other similar events in the past.  We were also part of the action; we all took part in the outrage, in the mourning, in the investigation, in the news cycle.  Bostonians tweeted and Instagrammed and Facebooked the heck out of the eerie quiet of their streets after the police ordered the city shut down.  They shared their anxieties and their hopes and the rest of us followed closely.

The crisis is over.  National Library Week is over too.  But what lingers--just one of the many senses that lingers--is that the current state of information technology ensures that there will never again be any such thing as a ‘local,’ ‘isolated’ incident.  Not in this country.  From here on out, we’re sharing everything.

It seems appropriate to me that the fire at the JFK Library was part of the initial mass of confusion on the day of the bombings.  Even now I can’t say with any certainty whether that had anything to do with the attack.  As things unfolded, confusion mounted, and the media did a really poor job of keeping us informed.  First we were misinformed, and at various points were we over-informed, but we were never quite just informed to the appropriate degree.  Some outlets did significant social and personal damage by seeming to incite neighbor to attack neighbor in one of the grimmest examples of media malfeasance I can remember.

Social media did its part to furrow brows during the five-day siege, as well.  Police had to request that overzealous Tweeple not broadcast the movements of investigators for fear of alerting the suspects to their movements.  It’s unclear what damage, if any, was done before that ban took effect--and the ban itself has troubling implications for the limits of First Amendment rights in the digital age.

Then came the capture of the surviving suspect, and with it the curious melange of celebration, bloodlust, confrontation, conversation and grandstanding that can only exist online.  I took part in a bit of it myself, against my better judgment.

It all goes to show that data and information do not merely sit, supine, before our eyes.  They don’t reside meekly behind our computer screens.  They are living, and they are wild, and they can possess us even as we create them.

It had been my intention before all this happened to start a library-focused blog this week.  It was National Library Week!  Perfect timing! Then we had a national tragedy and I held off, not sure if I should dive in at all until all was said and done, even if it meant missing out on ALA-promoted professional holy week synergy.  

But seeing all the missteps and pitfalls of media and social media this week, as well as the shining potential of both of them to be used as practical tool and as existential comfort--to connect the isolated, to bring together divergent viewpoints, to build understanding--I knew that just because Library Week had been superseded to a certain degree, these past five days had not at all lost their relevance to the serious consideration of the role of information professionals in our society.

I’m not at all prepared to say exactly what I mean by all this.  I’m not making any policy proposals, I’m not saying there should be librarian editors to every tweet or that police should hire us as consultants on free expression rights; I’m not saying that Wolf Blitzer could use a stern talking-to about recognizing valid sources of information and the etiquette of releasing information so gathered.  I might say all or some of those things later, but not right now.  I’m just saying that the events of this week have given me, in a very timely fashion, the most precious gift one can receive--something to think about.

Now, what will this blog be about?  A lot of things.  Some boring to some of you, a lot fun to most of you.  Most of it will be library related.  Some will be information science related.  A fair amount will be related to my interests, delivered with a librarian-relevant spin.

I do intend it to be somewhat radical.  I don’t count myself among those who think my profession is totally stagnant, but I am willing to give it a kick in the fanny when I think it deserves it.

So, just to run down some of the major features you can expect to see:

Librarianist Philosophy: I’ll be outlining my personal and constantly-evolving philosophy on what it means to be a librarian and information professional.  Everything that I think we must do and must be and how we must be and do them.  When one of them crystallizes in my mind, I’ll write a post on it.
Library Profiles: I like visiting libraries.  Now that I know what to look for, I like to enumerate for myself the pros and cons of a given library.  I will be sharing these enumerations with you, generally in the form of annotated photo essays.  Hewing to my biggest interests, I’ll focus on programming, layout and design, and collections of graphic novels, board games, etc., but I’ll try to touch on other important factors too.  (OPACs, I’m looking at you!)  I am happy to look at any sort of library and hope to collect quite a few from across the country and around the world.
Reviews: I’m most interested in doing board game reviews, because they’re my latest obsession and I think they pose an interesting challenge in terms of how to critique them.  It’s something I’m still learning about, so bear with me! I’ll also probably review graphic novels and books, as well as ‘library stuff’ like podcasts, webinars, conferences, conventions and classes I attend.  (Watch for my take on my first ALA conference later in the summer!)
Curricula:  I’m a big autodidact and I have a fascination with how to put together intellectual content to make it into something that not only informs, but instructs.  I’ve been following personal curricula for a few topics of interest since finishing grad school, and I’m interested in sharing my work with the world, since I’ve been doing it for nothing but my own edification.  (And maybe someday my employer will give me retroactive CEUs for them if I belabor it enough on here!)
Cool Tools: I keep coming across neat ways to present information.  I’ll try to share as many of these as I can.

And probably lots of other stuff as it occurs to me. Including superhero drawings and gifs of puppies doing cute things and reviews of Game of Thrones episodes (SPOILER ALERT).  I may also shamelessly promote the programs I develop at my two volunteer gigs, the Dunkirk Free Library and Dunkirk Historical Museum.

I hope some of you join me in figuring things out as we go along.  Thanks, everyone.